US Fiscally Transparent LLC qualifies as a US Tax Resident

by | Sep 18, 2024

The Indian tax authorities have denied treaty benefits to fiscally transparent entities such as foreign partnership firms and limited liability corporations (LLCs) on the ground that such entities are not liable to tax in their home country and do not qualify as tax residents of that country.  The taxpayers have been claiming treaty benefits by arguing that the members of such firms/LLCs, who are tax residents of the same country, pay taxes in that country on the income earned by the firms/LLCs.

In the recent General Motors USA tax case, this issue arose in the context of a US-based LLC. The Delhi Tribunal has held that as the income of the LLC is clubbed in the hands of its owner who merely discharges the tax that is assessable on the LLC, an LLC is essentially “liable to tax.” Further, the tax residency certificate (TRC) supports this fact and also confirms the status of the taxpayer as a body corporate. The Mumbai Tribunal had, in the Linklaters tax case, allowed the benefit of India-UK treaty to a fiscally transparent partnership firm, i.e., Linklaters.

It will be interesting to see how the courts implement this ruling especially as the Central Board of Direct Taxes has chosen not to adopt Article 3 of the MLI (multilateral convention to implement tax treaty related measures to prevent base erosion and profit shifting), which grants treaty benefits to fiscally transparent entities.

More News

Akil Hirani interviewed by The Legal 500

Original source: Legal500.com Akil Hirani, Managing Partner and Head of Transactions, outlines the philosophy of the firm and explains how the firm is adapting to client needs. What do you see as the main points that differentiate Majmudar & Partners from your...

read more

Karnataka Gig Worker Law

The Karnataka government has recently issued the Karnataka Platform-Based Gig Workers (Social Security and Welfare) Bill, 2024 (Bill) and has invited objections/ suggestions from stakeholders.  The provisions of the Bill will apply to all platform aggregators in...

read more

India – Press Note 3 Update

A recent press report suggests that the Indian government is likely to clear joint venture proposals involving Chinese companies like Haier, Suzhou Innovance, China Highly Group and others where the Indian partner has a majority shareholding in the joint venture. In...

read more

No GST on slump sale transactions in India

In an important ruling in the Piramal Enterprises Limited’s case under the erstwhile VAT statute, the Bombay High Court (BHC) has reiterated that a business transfer as a going concern is to be treated as a slump sale, and the assets of the business cannot be...

read more

Benchmark Litigation Rankings 2024

We are pleased to share that we have been ranked for multiple practice areas in the Benchmark Litigation 2024 rankings. Firm Rankings Labour and Employment White-collar Crime Commercial and Transactions Insolvency International Arbitration Government and Regulatory...

read more