Indian Income Tax Appellate Tribunal classifies rights as capital assets

by | Aug 27, 2020

Following a Karnataka High Court decision, in a recent case, the Bangalore Bench of the Indian Income-tax Appellate Tribunal has held that the relinquishment of rights under an agreement are capital assets, and thus, the income arising from such relinquishment is taxable as capital gains.

The expression “capital asset” has been defined under Indian tax law to mean “property of any kind”, subject to certain exclusions. Indian courts have examined this issue and held that contractual rights such as leasehold rights, subscription rights to shares of a company, rights to obtain a sale deed, and rights to title over immovable property are capital assets.

However, in the Vodafone case, India’s Supreme Court (Justice S. Radhakrishnan in his separate judgment) explicitly stated that contractual rights in an agreement do not sound in “property”, and hence, cannot, in the absence of a statutory stipulation, be considered as capital assets. We are not sure why the Vodafone judgment was not brought to the notice of the Tribunal. The issue will remain open pending a higher court ruling.

More News

ITR World Tax Leaders 2023

Akil Hirani, Managing Partner (tax controversy), and Ravi S. Raghavan, Partner - Tax (indirect tax, tax controversy), have been ranked as 'Highly Regarded' lawyers in the ITR World Tax Leaders rankings for 2023. Congratulations.

read more

Majmudar & Partners IFLR Rankings 32nd Edition

Majmudar & Partners has been recognized among the IFLR1000 for its 32nd Edition in various fields of practice and across sectors. The firm has been ranked for its excellence in practice areas such as M&A, private equity, banking, project finance, capital...

read more

Akil Hirani quoted by The Economic Times on the NDTV takeover

The Adani Group recently announced that its media unit was set to buy a majority stake in NDTV. Akil Hirani, Managing Partner and Head of Transactions Practice, was quoted by The Economic Times on the topic. "NDTV can adopt the classic takeover defence of bringing in...

read more

India – Insolvency Update

In the case of Somesh Choudhary v. Knight Riders Sports Private Limited & Ors, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) has held that claims arising from the grant of an exclusive right and license to use intellectual property rights falls...

read more

India – Employment Update

Under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, normally, the termination of a fixed term contract does not elicit payment of retrenchment compensation to the contractual worker, unlike the termination of an open-ended employment agreement. In the recent case of Jamnagar...

read more

Withdrawal of Personal Data Protection Bill

On August 3, 2022, the Indian government withdrew the Personal Data Protection Bill (the “Bill”), which was first introduced in Parliament on December 11, 2019, and had been thoroughly analysed by a Joint Committee of Parliament (“JCP”). To a Bill which had 99...

read more