Delhi High Court: Indian parties free to choose foreign law to govern arbitration between them

Dec 9, 2020

Recently, in the case of Dholi Spintex Pvt Ltd v. Louis Dreyfus Company India Pvt Ltd, the Delhi High Court (DHC) held that two Indian parties can agree to a foreign law governing the arbitration. In this case, the DHC relied on GMR Energy Limited vs. Doosan Power System India Ltd. & Ors. and Reliance Industries & Anr. vs. Union of India, and held that as there was a foreign element involved, three sets of law could apply to the arbitration, i.e., (i) the proper law of the contract (substantive law); (ii) the proper law of the arbitration agreement (law governing the agreement); and (iii) the proper law of the conduct of arbitration or curial law (the law governing the conduct of the arbitration). The DHC held that as the arbitration agreement is an independent agreement, it may be governed by a proper law of its own, which need not be the same as the substantive law. Here, the two Indian parties had agreed to an international commercial arbitration governed by English law as there was a foreign element involved in the contract, i.e., the parties had contractually agreed to pass on the property in goods from the Defendant to the Plaintiff in a place beyond the territorial waters of India.

Indian courts permitting Indian parties to arbitrate under a foreign law seems a positive step.

About the Author

Neerav Merchant Author Majmudar & PartnersNeerav Merchant, Partner at Majmudar & Partners has over 22 years of experience in dispute resolution, arbitration, litigation, enforcement of foreign judgments and awards, asset recovery, technology and telecommunication, intellectual property, employment, anti-corruption, and real property matters.

He regularly speaks at several international forums, including seminars and conferences hosted by Asian Legal Business, International Bar Association, and Law Society of England and Wales. He is on the panel of arbitrators of Mumbai Centre for International Arbitration.

Read more about him here.

More Insights

India’s Budget 2022-23 – key highlights

Introduction India’s Union Budget (the “Budget”) was announced on February 1, 2022, and the Finance Bill, 2022 (the “Finance Bill”) was tabled in Parliament.  The Finance Bill will be discussed in Parliament before its enactment, and therefore, it is likely that...

read more

An analysis of India’s Mediation Bill, 2021

Background In December 2021, the Union Law Minister tabled the draft Mediation Bill (the “Bill”) in parliament.  Due to significant opposition, the Bill was sent to the Committee on Law and Justice for further scrutiny.  This article lists out some salient...

read more

India’s Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019 – an update

Background In December 2019, India’s Ministry of Electronics, and Information Technology tabled the Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019 (the “PDP Bill”) in the Lok Sabha.  However, the PDP Bill, as drafted, raised several issues and challenges in implementing a...

read more

SEBI’s proposed changes to preferential issue guidelines

The SEBI has released a consultation paper on the preferential issue guidelines prescribed under Chapter V of SEBI (Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2018 (the “ICDR Regulations”), along with the recommendations discussed below. Rukshad Davar,...

read more
Share This